Fully Covered
You can insure your income against disability. You can’t insure it against Hashem. So what exactly are we buying?
Contents7 sections
An insurance agent once sat across from me and made his pitch for disability insurance.
“You have a good income,” he said. “But what happens if you become disabled? Your income disappears. What will you live on? Who will take care of you? You can’t depend on other people.”
It was a good argument. And it got me thinking.
Hundreds of other ways
I started counting all the ways a person’s income can disappear without him becoming disabled at all.
His industry can collapse. His business can fail. Technology can replace his skill. A major client can leave. The economy can turn. He may have to stop working to care for a family member. He can make one bad decision. Or he can simply reach a stage of life where the old income isn’t there anymore.
I can insure myself against one catastrophe.
Hashem has a hundred others.
Which leads to the real question: where exactly am I putting my bitachon?
Insurance as a necessity
In America, insurance has quietly moved into the same category as food and rent. Health, car, home, life, disability, umbrella, and then extra coverage on top of the coverage.
We don’t think of it as a financial decision anymore. It’s simply something you must have.
That isn’t wrong in itself. The Torah wants hishtadlus. We lock our doors, wear seatbelts, go to doctors and make sensible plans. There are good reasons, halachic and practical, to buy insurance.
The question is what is happening inside the person.
There is a world of difference between:
I’m taking reasonable precautions, and I know my life is in Hashem’s hands.
and:
I need to make sure that no matter what happens, I will never be vulnerable.
The first is hishtadlus.
The second slowly becomes a replacement for bitachon.
Handed over to the policy
The Chovos HaLevavos warns about exactly this. A person has to trust in someone, he says. If not in Hashem, then in something else. And then:
וּמִי שֶׁבּוֹטֵחַ בְּזוּלַת ה׳ מֵסִיר הָאֱלֹקִים הַשְׁגָּחָתוֹ מֵעָלָיו וּמַנִּיחַ אוֹתוֹ בְּיַד מִי שֶׁבָּטַח עָלָיו
Whoever trusts in something other than Hashem, Hashem removes His watchful care from him and leaves him in the hands of what he trusted.
Read that with your insurance policy in mind. If my real security is the policy, I have been handed over to the policy. To its fine print, its exclusions, and an adjuster on the phone.
That is a frightening place to live.
The fantasy of full coverage
Listen to the words we use. Full coverage. Comprehensive coverage. Covered for everything.
What if I get sick? What if the house burns? What if the car is totaled? Another policy. Another rider. Another layer. Until we’ve built a high wall around ourselves, and the wall whispers: nothing can happen to me.
But it’s an illusion. Hashem doesn’t need to use the scenario we insured against. He can simply change our life in a different way.
The Gemara has sharp words for this:
כָּל מִי שֶׁיֵּשׁ לוֹ פַּת בְּסַלּוֹ וְאוֹמֵר ״מָה אוֹכַל לְמָחָר״ — אֵינוֹ אֶלָּא מִקְּטַנֵּי אֲמָנָה
He has bread in his basket today, and he is already worried about tomorrow. Chazal call him one of the small in faith.
So it’s worth asking honestly: how much of my money am I spending trying to remove uncertainty from a world that Hashem built with uncertainty in it?
The tool and the source
Picture someone whose house just burned down.
The American answer comes right away: Don’t worry, insurance will cover it.
The Torah’s answer starts somewhere else: Hashem runs the world. If this happened, Hashem will take care of me.
That doesn’t mean he shouldn’t have had insurance. It means that even with insurance, his security isn’t coming from the insurance company. Hashem decided he would have the policy, that it would cover this, that the company would pay, and what would happen next.
The policy is a kli.
It isn’t the source.
Afraid to need anyone
There is another layer underneath the insurance mindset.
The pitch was never only you’ll have money. It was you won’t have to depend on anyone. You won’t be a burden on your family.
It sounds responsible. But ask yourself: why are we so afraid of needing another person? And why are we so uncomfortable with someone needing us?
The Torah built a whole system on the opposite idea. There are poor people and people who can help them. Sick people and people who can care for them. That isn’t a flaw in the design. It is the design.
We think the poor person needs the rich person’s money. But the poor person is giving the rich person something too: a chance to give, to break his selfishness, to loosen his grip on money, and to fulfill one of the great mitzvos of the Torah.
So when I tell myself I must make sure nobody will ever need me, I may be insuring myself against an entire part of my avodah.
Where bitachon really begins
Bitachon isn’t nothing bad will happen to me.
Bitachon is whatever happens, Hashem is running it.
The house burns down: Hashem is there. The business collapses: Hashem is there. I get sick, my income disappears, I suddenly need someone’s help: Hashem is there.
It’s easy to say Hashem will take care of me when everything is already taken care of. The real test comes when I’m no longer fully covered.
So buy the insurance if it’s sensible. Save, plan, protect your family. Just remember what all of it is.
The policy can cover the car.
Only Hashem covers your life.
The week’s writings, every Friday
One short email before Shabbos with everything new. Nothing else.