Lev Ladaas

Writings · Emunah

When a Jewish Magazine Leaves You Feeling Dark

Frum writers, frum ads, even a Torah column. So why did I close it feeling the same heaviness I get from the secular news?

· 5 min read

Contents8 sections
  1. Hashem-free
  2. Hashem as a disclaimer
  3. A different universe
  4. What the ads are teaching
  5. It comes into the home
  6. Emunah isn’t a garnish
  7. Whoever holds the pen
  8. What the darkness was telling me

I recently read a Jewish magazine. A normal frum one: Jewish articles, Jewish ads, Jewish people, Jewish topics.

When I put it down, I felt strangely low. A heaviness, almost a feeling of doom. The same feeling I sometimes get after reading the secular news or scrolling through social media.

How can a Jewish magazine leave me feeling like that?

Hashem-free

So I went back and thought about what I had actually read, and I noticed something. Almost all of it had been Hashem-free.

Not kefirah. Nothing against the Torah. There was even a Torah column somewhere in the middle. But the emotional world of the magazine was problems. People struggling, schools in trouble, politics, rising costs, families who can’t keep up, jobs that are hard to find, a society that keeps getting harder.

And then, at the end of an article, one paragraph: Of course, we have to remember that everything is from Hashem.

That isn’t the same as living in a world where Hashem is present.

Hashem as a disclaimer

Picture an article that spends every paragraph on what went wrong, who caused it, why it’s getting worse and what we must do about it. The last line adds, but we know everything is in Hashem’s hands.

Technically, Hashem is there. Emotionally, He was absent for the whole article and added at the end, like a disclaimer.

That matters more than we think. The mind doesn’t only take in sentences. It takes in a worldview, the whole atmosphere of what it reads.

A different universe

A Jew is meant to see the world through a completely different lens:

אַתָּה הׇרְאֵתָ לָדַעַת כִּי ה׳ הוּא הָאֱלֹקִים אֵין עוֹד מִלְּבַדּוֹ

Devarim 4:35

We don’t understand why everything happens. But we know there is a manhig, that nothing is random, and that life isn’t a battle between politicians, bosses, schools, doctors, inflation and circumstances. The Ribono Shel Olam is running all of it.

Spend two hours reading material where Hashem barely exists, and your mind slips into a different universe. Not because you became a kofer, but because you’ve been practicing a way of thinking where Hashem isn’t part of the picture. Then you close the magazine, and your neshamah feels that something is missing.

What the ads are teaching

It wasn’t only the articles. It was the advertisements.

So much advertising runs on three things: kinah, taavah and kavod. Look at me. Have what I have. Wow them. Stand out. Indulge. None of it says “don’t believe in Hashem.” But underneath every one of them is the same message: your happiness is out there, and you have to buy it. A better car, kitchen, outfit, meal, status, image.

Before you saw the ad, you were fine. You weren’t thinking about your kitchen, or whether people were impressed with you, or that particular donut. Then the ad tells you that you’re missing something, and now you feel it.

That is the engine of advertising: create a lack, then sell the solution.

Live in that long enough and you walk through life asking what am I missing? instead of what am I being given? That is the opposite of what the Torah trains us to see. The Torah teaches us to notice the tovah, to say thank you, and to know that Hashem is giving all the time. Not to ignore problems, but never to let the problems become the definition of reality.

It comes into the home

This gets more serious when we remember where these magazines are read. They come home for Shabbos. A husband reads, a wife reads, the children look through it. It doesn’t only give the family information. It creates an atmosphere.

A person may not remember a single sentence, but he remembers how it made him feel. Did he come away feeling Hashem is taking care of me, or the world is dangerous and I have to protect myself? I have so much, or everyone has more than me? I’m surrounded by people I can help, or I have to keep other people’s problems away from me?

Those aren’t small differences. They are different worlds.

Emunah isn’t a garnish

The Torah describes itself this way:

דְּרָכֶיהָ דַרְכֵי־נֹעַם וְכׇל־נְתִיבוֹתֶיהָ שָׁלוֹם. עֵץ־חַיִּים הִיא לַמַּחֲזִיקִים בָּהּ וְתֹמְכֶיהָ מְאֻשָּׁר

Mishlei 3:17-18

Torah is meant to change how we experience life: to bring yishuv hadaas, menuchas hanefesh, emunah, bitachon and hakaras hatov. It doesn’t make every problem vanish. It means the person facing the problem isn’t facing it alone. He sees Hashem inside it.

But we often treat emunah like a garnish. An article about a school crisis, then of course, we must remember Hashem. An article about money, then we need bitachon. A בס״ד at the top, a סייעתא דשמיא somewhere in the middle, and we feel we’ve made it Jewish.

Emunah isn’t a decoration. It’s the lens the whole picture is seen through. Not problem plus Hashem, but Hashem, and everything that happens inside His world.

Whoever holds the pen

This is a responsibility for anyone who makes Jewish content: writers, editors, publishers, advertisers, and anyone making a podcast, a video or a website. We aren’t only passing on information. We’re passing on thoughts, and thoughts become feelings, and feelings shape how a person lives his life.

So before publishing anything, it’s worth asking: what am I teaching this reader to notice, to want, to fear, and to believe about the world? And when he finishes, will he feel closer to Hashem, or further away?

That doesn’t mean every article must become a mussar shmuess with Hashem is amazing! tacked onto each paragraph. It means we can write about real problems without making Hashem disappear. Poverty, and still see chessed. Business, and still see hashgachah. Illness, and still know we aren’t in control. Politics, without making politicians the manhig of the world. Money, without making money our security. And ads that don’t keep feeding kinah, taavah and kavod.

What the darkness was telling me

When I put that magazine down, I couldn’t explain the heaviness. Now I think my neshamah noticed what my mind had missed. For an hour or two I had been living in a world with plenty of Jews and plenty of Jewish words, but very little Hashem.

A world without Hashem really is frightening. If everything is random, if people control everything, if money decides our future, if our happiness depends on what we own, of course we feel dark.

Bring Hashem back into the picture, and nothing outside changes. Same bills, same schools, same politics, same challenges. But now Hashem is here, and that is where serenity begins.

The real test of a Jewish magazine isn’t how many Torah words are inside. It’s what happens to a Jew’s neshamah when he closes it.

Share this article

Print as a gilyon

In the print window, choose “Save as PDF” to keep a copy.

Press Esc to close