Torah Is Therapy
A child can spend thousands of hours learning Torah and come home more anxious, angry and afraid. What exactly are we teaching him?
Contents9 sections
We have to rethink what it means to teach Torah.
Our educational system can sometimes make Torah look like academia. A child learns to read. He learns the material, the Gemara, the questions and answers. He takes a test, gets a grade, moves up a level.
All of that has value. But it cannot be the definition of success in Torah education. Torah is not just information. Torah is supposed to transform a person.
Dovid HaMelech says:
תּוֹרַת ה׳ תְּמִימָה מְשִׁיבַת נָפֶשׁ
The Torah of Hashem is complete; it restores the soul.
That word is enormous: מְשִׁיבַת נָפֶשׁ. The purpose of Torah is not to put more information into the brain. It is to restore the נֶפֶשׁ: to calm it, refine it and raise it. To change the way a person thinks, feels, speaks, reacts, wants, and relates to other people.
So what is a Torah teacher?
A Torah teacher is not an information-delivery system.
In a certain sense, a Torah teacher is a therapist of the nefesh. Not in the clinical sense, but as a person whose job is to use Torah to help another human being become healthier, more balanced, and more attached to Hashem. Because that is what Torah is supposed to do.
Chazal say Torah is acquired through 48 things. Among them are humility, joy, fear of Heaven, patience, loving Hashem, loving people, and being happy with one’s portion:
בְּיִרְאָה, בַּעֲנָוָה, בְּשִׂמְחָה… בְּאֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם… וְהַשָּׂמֵחַ בְּחֶלְקוֹ… אוֹהֵב אֶת הַמָּקוֹם, אוֹהֵב אֶת הַבְּרִיּוֹת
Chazal don’t describe the successful Torah student as someone who answers questions quickly. They describe a different kind of human being.
A person who learns Torah should slowly become more humble, more patient, more joyful, more compassionate. Less controlled by his ego. Better able to accept correction. More at peace with himself. More interested in truth than in winning. More able to love another Jew. More connected to Hashem.
That’s what it means for Torah to enter a person.
The test of Torah
This gives us a different way to judge a classroom.
We usually ask: Did the children learn the material? Did they finish the sugya? Did they get good marks?
Those questions matter. But there is a more important one:
What is happening to the nefesh of these children because of the Torah they are learning?
After an hour in that classroom, is the child more connected to Hashem? More humble, more peaceful, more loving? Better at handling frustration? Able to see his own ego? Does he leave feeling that Torah gives life to his soul, or just knowing another piece of information?
If a child can spend thousands of hours learning Torah and become more anxious, more angry, more arrogant, more afraid, we have to ask ourselves a serious question:
What exactly are we teaching him?
The great paradox
There is something almost tragic here. A child can spend his whole day surrounded by the most healing wisdom in the world, and come home worse than when he left.
He spent the day learning:
וְאָהַבְתָּ לְרֵעֲךָ כָּמוֹךָ
דַּעֲלָךְ סְנֵי לְחַבְרָךְ לָא תַּעֲבֵיד
הֱוֵי דָן אֶת כָּל הָאָדָם לְכַף זְכוּת
אֵיזֶהוּ עָשִׁיר, הַשָּׂמֵחַ בְּחֶלְקוֹ
וְנַפְשִׁי כֶּעָפָר לַכֹּל תִּהְיֶה
He learned about emunah, bitachon, humility, patience, kindness, forgiveness, self-control and gratitude.
And yet he comes home angry. He is terrified of making a mistake. He hates himself when he fails. He keeps comparing himself to other children. He feels that Hashem is disappointed in him, that his Rebbe is disappointed in him, that his value depends on his grades, that if he doesn’t perform he is nothing.
That should make us stop.
The problem isn’t that the child needs less Torah. The problem may be that we haven’t yet figured out how to make the Torah reach the place in him that needs it most.
Torah is supposed to reach the heart
Imagine a medicine that contains everything a sick person needs. But you never give it to him in a way he can absorb. You put the bottle next to him and say, “Know what’s inside.”
He can memorize the ingredients. He can pass a test on them. He can explain exactly what the medicine is supposed to do.
But he hasn’t been healed.
That can happen with Torah. A child can know Torah without letting Torah work on him. He can know what the Mishnah says without asking: “What is Hashem saying to me through this Mishnah?”
He can learn about patience without noticing where Hashem is asking him to be more patient. He can learn about humility without seeing his own ego, and about emunah without noticing where he is afraid. He can learn בֵּין אָדָם לַחֲבֵרוֹ without realizing how he treats the child sitting next to him.
The information entered his brain. It never reached his nefesh.
Davening is the clearest example
Tefillah is not a performance where a child recites a sequence of Hebrew words for fifteen minutes. It is an encounter.
A person stands before Hashem and speaks to Him. He asks for what he needs. He thanks Him. He admits what he doesn’t have. He gives Him his worries, and reconnects.
In that sense, tefillah is a therapy session with Hashem. A person walks in feeling one way and is supposed to walk out different.
Maybe he came in worried, and leaves with bitachon. Maybe he came in angry, and leaves with perspective. Maybe he came in feeling alone, and leaves remembering that Hashem is with him. Maybe he came in feeling that everything depends on him, and leaves remembering that there is a רִבּוֹנוֹ שֶׁל עוֹלָם running the world.
If a child finishes davening and all he has learned is how to pronounce the words correctly, we have taught him how to say tefillah. We have not necessarily taught him how to daven.
The teacher’s job changes
Once we see this, the teacher’s whole mindset changes.
Before walking into the classroom, the Rebbe shouldn’t only ask, “What am I going to teach today?” He should also ask:
“Who are these children going to become because of what I teach today?”
And deeper still:
“What does Hashem want to do inside these children through this Torah?”
Now the Gemara is more than questions and answers. A disagreement between two Tannaim can teach a child how to disagree without hating. A halacha can teach him that truth sometimes takes self-control. A story about a tzaddik can show him what a human being can become. A mussar teaching can give him words for his own ego. A teaching about Hashem can give a frightened child somewhere to put his fear.
The Torah becomes a mirror, a compass, and medicine.
The classroom as a workshop for the nefesh
Maybe we should stop thinking of the classroom as a place where information is deposited into children, and think of it as a workshop for the nefesh.
The Rebbe isn’t filling vessels. He’s working with human beings.
Every child walks in carrying an invisible world. One is scared. One is angry. One feels stupid. One feels superior. One is lonely. One badly wants approval. One has great potential but doesn’t believe in himself. One is struggling with jealousy. One is carrying something nobody knows about.
And the Rebbe holds something extraordinarily powerful in his hands: Torah.
The question is not only whether he can get the child to understand the Torah. It is whether he can help the child feel what the Torah is trying to do to him.
The goal is deveikus
All of this leads to one place: deveikus.
The goal isn’t children who know a lot of Torah. It is human beings who are attached to Hashem. A child should slowly come to know:
“Hashem is real. Hashem is with me. Hashem cares about me. Hashem is asking something of me.”
“Torah is His message to me. When I learn, Hashem is talking to me. When I daven, I’m talking to Hashem.”
“When I work on my middos, I’m becoming the person Hashem wants me to be.”
That is Torah education.
The grades, the knowledge and the achievement are important. But they are the vehicle, not the destination. The destination is a human being whose nefesh has been changed by Torah.
A different question for every Rebbe
Perhaps every lesson plan needs one more question. Not only:
“What do I want them to know when the lesson is over?”
But:
“What do I want them to become?”
And deeper still: “How should this Torah make their lives better tomorrow morning?”
If a child learns about patience, where will he use it? If he learns about gratitude, what will he notice tonight? If he learns about judging someone favorably, who will he look at differently tomorrow? If he learns about emunah, where will he be less afraid? If he learns about Hashem, where will he feel closer to Him?
That is when Torah stops being something the child knows and becomes something the child lives. That may be the difference between teaching a child Torah and teaching him how to receive Torah.
Torah is not supposed to stay on the page. It is supposed to enter the person. And when it does, it does what Dovid HaMelech told us:
תּוֹרַת ה׳ תְּמִימָה מְשִׁיבַת נָפֶשׁ
It doesn’t just make the child smarter. It makes him whole.
The week’s writings, every Friday
One short email before Shabbos with everything new. Nothing else.